Campaigns Wales

Decision on plan to ‘ban’ new HMOs due within days

Sally Walmsley
Written by Sally Walmsley

Plans to severely restrict the number of new shared houses in two popular student areas of Cardiff will be decided this week.

Cardiff Council is set to vote on the proposed Supplementary Planning Guidance (SPG) that will severely restrict new houses in multiple occupation (HMOs) in the city, particularly in Cathays and Plasnewydd.

The council put forward the proposal for arbitrary HMO thresholds claiming there is currently ‘a disproportionate number’ of HMOs in the city.

Landlords will be refused planning permission to create a new HMO if there is already a certain density of similar homes in the area under the plans.

The threshold for Cathays and Plasnewyedd is 20 percent and in all other wards 10 percent. Any properties falling within a 50m radius of the proposed new HMO will be considered when making the decision. If more than 20% are already licensed HMOs, then it would be considered unacceptable.

The Residential Landlords Association is arguing vehemently against the proposals, with the support of Cardiff Students’ Union.

Douglas Haig, RLA Director and Vice-Chairman for Wales said: “This policy is discriminatory and attacks those on lower incomes and some of the most vulnerable in society. HMOs provide more affordable accommodation to a wide range of groups, not just students, as explicitly stated in the guidance itself.

“By effectively banning them you are restricting the total accommodation available, with consequences for rent levels which will increase.”

Areas with high proportions of HMOs have been associated with waste management and anti-social behavior problems –   issues local authorities said would be improved through Additional Licensing back in 2014.

The RLA had argued against Additional Licensing, pointing out the city council was already well-equipped to deal with problems like waste.  Now that these measures have failed, the council is looking to planning restrictions.

Mr Haig added: “This is another bureaucratic measure that will only impede community cohesion.  This will have impacts not only on the students, but on single working professionals, which landlords and the local area rely on greatly.”

Cardiff University Students’ Union has backs the association. Hollie Cooke, Vice President Welfare said: “By restricting, and essentially prohibiting the development of HMO’s in the Cathays areas, students will be forced to move into other areas of Cardiff.

“This will not only create greater costs for students as they travel further, it will also cause individuals to rent in areas that are not used to student neighbours, causing greater community cohesion problems.

“Safety becomes a greater concern, as the frequency of students having to walk longer distances in the dark will increase and with the same number of HMOs remaining, these restrictions do little to address the core problems highlighted, as the population density in Cathays remains the same.

“This is an unwelcome change, that will likely be detrimental to the student population, and do little to benefit the community in, and around, the Cathays area.”


About the author

Sally Walmsley

Sally Walmsley

Sally Walmsley is the Magazine and Digital Editor for the NRLA. With 20 years’ experience writing for regional and national newspapers and magazines she is responsible for editing our members' magazine 'Property', producing our articles for our news site, the weekly and monthly bulletins and editorial content for our media partners.

1 Comment

  • The commitment and investment of the Welsh government to develop a world renowned university in Cardiff is to be applauded. However the recent announcement of a substantial student housing project adjacent to the university should not be funded by restricting a variety of alternative accommodation for its students.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.